Disclosure: RustySkins is reader-supported. If you sign up through links or promo codes on this page, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. This never affects our ratings. How we make money.
Short answer: Tradeit.gg (8.9/10) is the stronger pick for pure skin-to-skin trading: bigger bot inventory, tighter effective spreads and 24/7 support. SkinSwap (8.3/10) earns its place when you want to end in money instead of items, with real-money cashouts including PayPal. Trade on Tradeit, cash out through SkinSwap or a marketplace: that’s how we’d split it after testing both.
Bot-trading sites live and die on two numbers: how deep the inventory is and how much the spread quietly costs you per swap. We measured both sites for our full reviews; here’s the head-to-head with our August 2026 test data.
Tradeit.gg vs SkinSwap at a glance
| Tradeit.gg (8.9) | SkinSwap (8.3) | |
|---|---|---|
| Core offer | Instant bot trading, Rust + CS2 | Instant trading + real-money cashout |
| Bot inventory | Very large ($5M+ / ~350,000 items at our check) | Large, Rust depth varies |
| Effective spread we saw | ~5 to 10% real cost per trade | ~10 to 14% bands |
| Cash out to money | Crypto (~2% fee) | Yes, including PayPal |
| Support | 24/7 | Standard hours, decent response |
| Trustpilot at our check | 4.7 (20,000+ reviews) | 4.3 |
The spread: what trading actually costs
No bot site charges a visible “fee” on swaps; the cost hides in the spread between what your skins are valued at and what theirs are priced at. In our testing that real cost ran roughly 5 to 10% per trade on Tradeit and 10 to 14% on SkinSwap. Marketing pages quote lower numbers on both; trust the basket math, not the banner. Rule of thumb: if you trade often, the spread difference compounds fast, and Tradeit’s tighter pricing is worth more than any signup bonus.
Cashing out: SkinSwap’s actual edge
Tradeit ends in items or crypto (around 2% cashout fee). SkinSwap ends in money, including PayPal, which neither Tradeit nor our top marketplace Skinport offers as a payout. That makes SkinSwap one of the few direct skin-to-PayPal routes that worked in our tests, with the fee caveat that instant convenience prices in: you net less than a patient peer-to-peer sale. The full math comparison between instant and patient selling is in our PayPal cash-out guide, and both platforms’ complete test logs are in the Tradeit.gg review and SkinSwap review.
When to use neither
If you’re converting a whole inventory to maximum cash and you’re not in a hurry, a peer-to-peer marketplace beats both: Skinport’s flat 8% undercuts every instant spread we measured. Bot sites buy you speed and skin-for-skin convenience, marketplaces buy you the best price. Decide which one you’re actually optimizing for before you start clicking; the trading site rankings and marketplace rankings cover both routes.
FAQ
Is Tradeit.gg or SkinSwap better for Rust?
Tradeit.gg (8.9) for trading: deeper inventory and a 5 to 10% effective spread against SkinSwap’s 10 to 14%. SkinSwap (8.3) for cashing out, because it pays real money including PayPal. Many players use exactly that split.
What does bot trading really cost?
The spread, not a fee: your items get valued low, theirs are priced high. We measured a real cost of roughly 5 to 10% per swap on Tradeit and 10 to 14% on SkinSwap in August 2026. Compare the same basket on both before any big trade.
Can I get PayPal money from these sites?
From SkinSwap, yes: it cashes out to real money including PayPal. Tradeit pays out in crypto (about 2% fee), not PayPal. For the best PayPal rate overall, a patient marketplace sale still nets more than any instant route.
Are bot trading sites safe?
The established ones are: both sites here use Steam’s official trade flow, so you never share credentials, and both completed our test trades without issues. The real risks are fake copycat domains and phishing links; type URLs yourself and verify the trade contents in the Steam confirmation, every time.
Last updated: August 2026 · Reviewed per our testing methodology. We re-review every platform every 90 days.